BACKGROUND: Internal rotation (IR) with reverse total shoulder arthroplasty (rTSA) can be unpredictable. Identifying the factors associated with loss of or improved IR could aid preoperative patient counseling. This study quantifies the change in IR experienced by rTSA patients with nonfracture indications and identifies the patient, implant, and operative factors associated with IR loss or gain at 2-year minimum follow-up. METHODS: A total of 1978 primary rTSA patients were analyzed from an international database of a single rTSA prosthesis to quantify IR at 2 years' minimum follow-up. rTSA patients were divided into 2 cohorts based on their preoperative IR score, with group 1 patients having less active IR as defined by a preoperative IR score ≤3 and group 2 patients having greater active IR as defined by a preoperative IR score ≥4 (ie, L5 or higher). For both group 1 and 2 patients, univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to quantify the risk factors associated with IR loss after rTSA. RESULTS: Overall, 58.9% of rTSA patients experienced IR improvement and 17.0% lost IR after rTSA. The occurrence of IR loss or gain was dependent on preoperative IR score, as 73.2% of group 1 patients improved IR and only 40.1% of group 2 patients improved IR, whereas 31.0% of group 2 patients lost IR and only 6.3% of group 1 patients lost IR after rTSA. Numerous risk factors for IR loss were identified. For group 1 patients, male sex (P = .004, odds ratio [OR] = 2.056), tobacco usage (P = .004, OR = 0.348), larger humeral stem diameter (P = .008, OR = 0.852), and not having subscapularis repaired (P = .002, OR = 2.654) were significant risk factors for IR loss. For group 2 patients, male sex (P = .005, OR = 1.656), higher body mass index (P = .002, OR = 0.946), a diagnosis other than osteoarthritis (P < .001, OR = 2.189), nonaugmented baseplate usage (P < .001, OR = 2.116), and not having subscapularis repaired (P < .001, OR = 3.052) were significant risk factors for IR loss. CONCLUSION: The majority of patients improve IR after rTSA in the nonfracture setting. rTSA patients with substantial IR prior to surgery had a greater probability for losing IR compared to patients with poor preoperative IR. Numerous risk factors for IR loss were identified; these risk factors are useful for counseling patients considering rTSA, as some patients are more likely to lose IR than others.